An innovative, open-ended geometry app used by thousands of students and educators, and endorsed by Apple-certified educators
Challenge
The challenge was to balance learning and curriculum with usability requirements for 5-7 year olds.
As primary schools were deploying iPads to their classrooms, teachers were telling us they had difficulty finding an app for teaching geometry.
In the classroom, teachers need tools that support classroom teaching without trying to replace the teacher.
Shape Lab in action
Discovery
Core functionality
For a greenfield project getting the core interaction right at the start is important so we don’t have to rebuild the app later.
I collaborated with the education team to interpret the relevant parts of the curriculum and translate those into activities students would need to undertake, and then broke those down into a list of tools needed.
A photo of a sketch pad showing sketches iterating on toolbar and icon ideas
We knew the main input would use handwriting recognition for creating shapes, but there were still a lot of tools that students would need to manipulate shapes.
A screenshot showing all gestures mapped to the action the trigger
I created prototypes to get feedback from the team using HTML and Javascript for a few different approached to presenting tools. I built them using a wireframe style so that feedback would be focused on the interactions and not the visual design.
Toolbar prototype 1
Toolbar prototype 2
Toolbar prototype 3
Validation
In-class validation
The best way to validate an app intended for classroom use is in the classroom, and testing in classrooms requires teaching an actual lesson.
We built a limited iPad app with the core functionality we needed to test, that students could use for a particular geometry lesson and organised with teachers to present the lesson in classes.
Then I developed a lesson plan with our resident teacher so that we could present a real lesson.
Real classroom testing
Research
Observations in the classroom
We learned that leading a lesson and giving students verbal instructions is easier when there are less steps, this meant that we needed to keep the tools always visible, and represent them with distinct icons, so that students could find them easily from a verbal instruction.
While observing students use the app, we noticed that if the app crashed that would usually fail to return to the assigned activity and start exploring other apps installed on the iPad.
Even with a teacher present students could quickly get pulled away from the lesson. Preventing crashes was important and we worked hard to find and fix them, but I recognised that we also needed to prevent students from accidentally closing a document while they were working.
Young students are still developing motor skills and with the close button close to other tools on the toolbar we needed a solution that prevented students from unintentionally closing the document they were working in.
I created a pull-to-close mechanism that would allow students to intentionally close a document while preventing accidental activations.
Impact
Impact
Shape Lab reached thousands of students and teachers. It was endorsed by Apple-certified Educators and featured by Apple in the App Store, featured by Teachers with Apps, as well as receiving 4 star rating by Common Sense Media.
Praise for Shape Lab from an Apple-certified educator
Reflection
In hindsight
Shape Lab was a feature rich app by the time it shipped. But it took a long time to ship, and when it did there was a lot of pressure to gain a lot of customers quickly. In hindsight shipping earlier with a tighter feature set focused on a specific lesson would have been more effective.
Shape Lab was featured by Apple in the App Store
It would have given educators time to learn from early-adopters and build familiarity, while also giving us the opportunity to see how teachers around the world were using the app in their classrooms and giving us feedback to iterate on.
I’ve regularly pushed for this approach in my roles since.
Any shape can be created by drawing it anywhere on the screen
Shapes can be flipped in a way that feels natural
Shapes can be cut into any number of segments
Users can take photos to investigate shapes in the real world
A freehand drawing overlay allows users to make contextual notes about their investigation
Users can investigate angles and relationships between sides
Rulers enable users to investigate relationships between shapes
Beyond maths users can also engage in creative expression
Snapping between shape vertices and edges allows user to create precise repeating patterns